The players highlighted in
gray were selected as starters through fan voting. Johnny Damon and Andruw
Jones were added to the team as the 30th man through online voting.
| POS | AMERICAN | NATIONAL |
| C | Jorge Posada, NY | Mike Piazza, NY |
| 1B | Jason Giambi, NY | Todd Helton, COL |
| 2B | Alfonso Soriano, NY | Jose Vidro, MON |
| 3B | Shea Hillenbrand, BOS | Scott Rolen, PHI |
| SS | Alex Rodriguez, TEX | Jimmy Rollins, PHI |
| OF |
Tori Hunter, MIN
Manny Ramirez, BOS Ichiro Suzuki, SEA |
Barry Bonds, SF
Vladimir Guerrero, MON Sammy Sosa, CHC |
| Bench |
A.J. Pierzynski, MIN
Tony Batista, BAL Nomar Garciaparra, BOS Derek Jeter, NY Paul Konerko, CHW Mike Sweeney, KC Miguel Tejada, OAK Robin Ventura, NY Omar Vizquel, OAK Garret Anderson, ANA Johnny Damon, BOS Robert Fick, DET Randy Winn, TB Mark Buerhle, CHW Freddy Garcia, SEA Eddie Guardado, MIN Roy Halladay, TOR Derek Lowe, BOS * Pedro Martinez, BOS Mariano Rivera, NY Kazuhiro Sasaki, SEA * Ugeth Urbina, BOS Barry Zito, OAK |
Damian Miller, ARZ
Benito Santiago, SF Luis Castillo, FLA Jose Hernandez, MIL Mike Lowell, FLA Richie Sexson, MIL Junior Spivey, ARZ Lance Berkman, HOU Adam Dunn, CIN Shawn Green, LA Luis Gonzalez, ARZ Andruw Jones, ATL Eric Gagne, LA Tom Glavine, ATL Trevor Hoffman, SD Randy Johnson, ARZ Byung-Hyun Kim, ARZ Matt Morris, STL Odalis Perez, LA Curt Schilling, ARZ John Smoltz, ATL Mike Williams, PIT |